CST Week 4 Scrapbook

CST Week 4 Scrapbook

Link: https://thinkprogress.org/the-fcc-just-decided-to-repeal-net-neutrality-heres-why-thats-really-really-bad-64e376ea04d3/

PDF: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1RUETXXhgSMuufkM4t14fe0tPry_2H_G4

Article Summary:

This article discusses the new proposal for the FCC to repeal net neutrality regulations and the negative impacts it may have on the country. The current regulation prohibits internet service providers from slowing down or blocking websites to its users. Ajit Pai, the current FCC Chairman, claims that repealing the regulations will help rural America and lead to better, faster, and cheaper internet access. The author believes that Mr. Pai is wrong. It is argued that startup internet companies will have a harder time competing with big corporations such as Verizon and ATT as the repeal in regulations will favor the larger corporations. This could stifle innovation as much innovation comes from small startup companies, ie the beginnings of Google and Facebook. The free access of speech would also be hindered as the internet service providers could essentially filter what they deem acceptable for their customer's to view.

Why it was Chosen:

I chose this article as I feel am passionate with regards to this subject. I feel that limiting the internet is inherently bad. This could lead to a country where only those with enough money will be able to have their website accessible to the masses. I believe the thoughts of every individual should have an equal opportunity to reach those on the internet. 

Ethical Implications

The ethical implication is that should people be entitled to open access to the internet. I believe we should. The article references the situation in Portugal where similar legislation has taken place. In Portugal, people choose their level of access to the internet based on the fee they pay. Imagine a public library having to offer a lower access internet due to fees placed on them. Students and adults with no internet access would only be able to access minimal content in their research. Favoritism in access to knowledge would only be given to those who could afford it. This is wrong and could further create a division in the lower and upper class in the country.

Credibility of Source

ThinkProgress is an online news site founded in 2005 that reports from a Progressive point of view. Being from a certain point of view, it is important to note the the site would lean towards the left on most of it's analysis.